Start by identifying the look you want and the conditions you’ll wear it in, then pick an LA Girl eyeliner pencil that matches those needs. For everyday polish, choose a natural shade in a soft, easy-glide pencil with a creamy formula. If you need long-lasting wear or water resistance, look for products marketed as long-wear or waterproof within the LA Girl line. Decide between wooden pencils (which require sharpening) and retractable or gel-style pencils for quick, mess-free application. Finally, consider your eye area sensitivity and choose a shade family that complements your skin tone and eye color.

Pigment payoff and finish drive how bold the line looks and how long it lasts, especially in LA Girl Glide Gel pencils. Higher pigment loads deliver richer color, while matte, satin, or shimmer finishes change how the line reads on your lid. Waterproof or long-wear formulas resist smudging through humidity and tears, though they may require a specific remover. Keep in mind that lid oils and application technique can affect wear, so choose a formula suited to your skin type and practice clean, thin strokes.

Beginners benefit from a softer, easy-glide pencil that allows forgiving application and straightforward sharpening. Pros often seek a pencil that delivers a precise line and longer wear, with control for wings and tightlining. For daily looks, a neutral shade with a subtle finish works well; for events, opt for deeper tones or metallics and a sharper tip. Start with clean lids and light, deliberate strokes to build confidence over time.

Keep LA Girl eyeliner pencils sharp and clean by regularly sharpening wooden pencils with a dedicated sharpener and wiping the tip. Cap pencils after use and store in a cool, dry place to prevent drying out. Do not share pencils to avoid infections, and replace them if the product becomes crumbly or dries out. Use a compatible eye makeup remover to take off the pencil without tugging at the delicate eye area.

Choose shade and finish to complement your eye shape and the eyeshadow you plan to wear. For almond or round eyes, a subtle tight line and a gentle wing can enhance shape, while hooded eyes benefit from a stronger lash-line line and a wing that opens the eye. Pair deep browns or blacks with neutral or metallic shadows for contrast, or use brighter tones to make eyes pop. Keep the pencil tip sharp for precise lines or opt for a softer stroke for a smoky look.